Comparison of boxcars, On2 cf On30

This series of pictures aims to illustrate a/. the difference in size between a 1/4 inch scale model of a Maine Two Foot boxcar and a typical ready to run boxcar in On30, and b/. the difference in ride heights between the same model boxcar built as an On2 model and one built to the common standards applied to On30.

On2vsOn30-01

The very low, close to the ground appearance of the On2 model is apparent in this shot. It is commonly stated that the body of Maine Two Foot freight car should overhang the trucks “like a well upholstered lady sitting on a bar stool”.

On2vsOn30-03

On2vsOn30-02

This shot also shows Trevor Marshalls’ method of simulating the seamed roof appearance using “tiles” of thin metal foil applied individually. Note that the latest research shows that all Maine Two Foot boxcars were built with tin roofs made from overlapping sheets, although the sheet size, laying patterns and method of attachment to the sub-roof did vary with builder and road, and sometimes build dates.

100_2125a

100_2126a

These two pictures show the same boxcar model, a B&SR 26 footer scratchbuilt by Terry Smith from his own urethane parts, built to common On30 standards on the left and to On2 standards on the right. The On30 model is shown on standard UK OO gauge train set track (his nephew’s) while the On2 model is shown on Precision Scale On2 Flex track.

The On30 model is shown with an early style urethane roof casting with rather pronounced raised seams (taped), whereas the On2 model is shown with a later style urethane roof casting with more subtle seams (embossed).

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s